Using Science to Describe Playing “On the Beat”

We pipers know that playing “on the beat” is critical, not only for unison in a group, but also to attain total musicality in the music we’re playing. However, as an individual how many of us have been told that we play “consistently ahead of the beat”, or that we are “sometimes on the beat, but not always”?

What kind of mental pictures do these descriptions of our piping conjure up?

Let’s start by defining “precise” and “accurate”, two words that may appear at first glance to mean the same thing. But, in fact, they describe two completely different concepts. The word precise means a “state of strict exactness”—how often something is strictly exact. Multiple measurements are needed to establish precision. Figure 1 helps to illustrate this concept.

figure-1-precise-but-not-accurate-300x225-7093391
Precise, but not accurate

Think of the target’s bull’s eye as representing the downbeat of a tune, regardless of the idiom or tempo. Anything to the left of the bull’s eye is ahead of the beat, and anything to the right of the bull’s eye is behind the beat. With respect to rhythm, this example shows a piper playing with great precision, but the playing is consistently ahead of the beat. Unfortunately, the playing is also inaccurate because not even a single note or gracenote was played on the beat.

On the other hand, the word accurate means the degree of conformity and correctness of something when compared to a true or absolute value. See Figure 2.

figure-2-accurate-but-not-precise-300x225-7235714
Accurate, but not precise

Something can be accurate on occasion as a fluke, but for something to be consistently and reliably accurate, it must also be precise. In this case, the piper is often perfectly on the beat, but not always. A few times he’s slightly ahead of the beat, and other times he’s behind the beat.

We should all strive for accuracy and precision in our playing, illustrated in Figure 3.

figure-3-accurate-and-precise-300x225-7771987
Both accurate and precise

This means that every single note or gracenote is played precisely and accurately on the beat.

figure-4-in-terms-of-rhythm-300x225-4216334
Using accuracy and precision in terms of playing on the beat.

Finally, Figure 4 represents the above concepts as they relate to the presence or lack of both precision and accuracy in terms of rhythm. Only through both precision and accuracy can a solo piper expect to bring out the best musicality of a tune, or a pipe band come anywhere close to playing in unison. In the latter, every piper in the band must play on the beat (accurate), every time (precise).

Related Articles

Tunes For Improving Rhythmic Accuracy

Rhythmic accuracy, scale navigation, grace note quality, embellishment quality, and ALAP/ASAP, are foundation skills on the Highland bagpipe. We must be able to accurate navigate the notes on the chanter, we must have crisp, clean grace notes and embellishments, and we must imply dynamics through ALAP/ASAP.

How to Use a Metronome to Learn a 2/4 March

When you are learning a new competition march, do you often have trouble staying “on the beat” because you are using all of your concentration just to play all of the melody notes, gracenotes and embellishments correctly? Then, after you get those pesky things out of the way, are you still having trouble getting that “march feel”? Using a metronome during your practice may well be a useful tool for you.

Responses